UN Appalled at Suffering in Myanmar's Muslim Camps
By Edith M. Lederer
June 18, 2014
A top U.N. humanitarian official said Tuesday she witnessed "appalling conditions" and the worst human suffering she has ever seen in camps for stateless Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar's violence-torn Rakhine State.
Assistant Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs Kyung-wha Kang told reporters that because of severe restrictions on their freedom of movement both in camps and isolated villages, many Muslims can't rebuild their lives and have "wholly inadequate access to basic services including health, education, water and sanitation."
Myanmar, a predominantly Buddhist nation of 60 million which only recently emerged from a half-century of military rule, considers the Rohingya Muslims to be immigrants from Bangladesh and denies them citizenship and related rights, even though many were born to families who arrived in the country generations ago.
Almost all of the 1.3 million Rohingya live in Rakhine state, where sectarian violence in the last two years has killed about 280 people and forced another 140,000 to flee their homes. Most of the victims have been Rohingyas chased down by Buddhist mobs. As a result, most Rohingya are now living in hot, dirty camps for internally displaced people, or IDPs.
Kang, who visited Myanmar last week to assess the humanitarian challenges, said that "in Rakhine, I witnessed a level of human suffering in IDP camps that I have personally never seen before" — and the Muslim camps were the worst.
One Rohingya camp Kang visited was very isolated, had no schools and was close to sea level so it was impossible to build effective latrines. The people couldn't leave and depended on assistance coming in for their basic needs, she said.
"It has already been two years," Kang said. "It's not a human situation to be locked into these desperate situations for any length of time."
She said the authorities insist there must be restrictions on movement in the Muslim camps for security reasons.
But Kang said freedom of movement is a basic human right, and the U.N. has urged Myanmar's government to expand freedom of movement for Muslims, "even with security considerations taken into account."
Kang also said there are major issues in delivering aid to IDPs in Rakhine.
Travel is difficult and there is "a huge amount of mistrust of U.N. humanitarian operations" because local Buddhist communities think U.N. assistance "is very biased in favor of the Muslims" despite the U.N.'s best efforts to deliver aid in an impartial manner, she said.
She also warned that unless Myanmar authorities bring the perpetrators of attacks on U.N. and humanitarian organizations in late March in Rakhine to justice, U.N. staff will continue to be at risk.
Kang said the United Nations is also engaged with the government to address the issue of statelessness — the root cause of the violence — and is pressing for changes in the legal system so Rohingyas can have a path to citizenship, but "there has not been much movement, admittedly, so far."